PPL (4s - 17)

A C1 speaking investigation

PRETTY LITTLE LIARS

The Suspicion Files

Aria. Mona. Mike. Ezra. Secrets, red flags, questionable decisions and the fine line between intuition and paranoia.

CONFIDENTIAL • CASE NO. 023
Your case begins

What would you believe?

Aria notices that Mona and her brother Mike seem to be getting closer. She does not know exactly what is going on. She starts asking questions, interpreting small details and wondering whether Mona can be trusted.

At the same time, Ezra's behaviour raises questions. Some things do not quite add up. Aria has to decide whether her suspicions are justified or whether she is jumping to conclusions.

Your role: You are not here to repeat the plot. You are a detective, psychologist and relationship expert. Examine the clues, challenge the characters' decisions and make your own judgement. The situations below are discussion scenarios, not claims that every detail happened exactly this way in the series.

Opening statement: choose your theory

There is no correct answer. You will revisit your theory at the end.

File 01 • Vocabulary revision

23 words. 23 clues.

Tap each card. The front gives you the English expression and pronunciation; the back gives you the Ukrainian meaning and an example connected to the mystery.

0 / 23 cards explored

File 02 • Match the evidence

Match the expressions

Choose an English expression on the left, then its meaning on the right. Correct pairs turn green. Can you solve all eight?

File 03 • Wordsearch

Find the hidden clues

Find all 10 words hidden horizontally or vertically. Tap the first letter and then the last letter of a word. Words may run forwards or backwards.

File 04 • The psychology of suspicion

Is Aria intuitive or impulsive?

Read each statement. Decide whether it is a reasonable conclusion, an assumption, or an example of emotional reasoning.

Evidence

Something observable that can be checked or supported.

Example: “He said he would be home at six, but arrived at ten without explaining why.”

Assumption

A belief accepted without enough proof.

Example: “He arrived late, so he must be hiding something.”

Emotional reasoning

Assuming that a feeling proves a fact.

Example: “I feel uncomfortable, therefore Mona must be lying.”

Detective test

1. Aria sees Mona and Mike talking quietly. She concludes that Mona is manipulating him.
2. Mike tells Aria that he and Mona have been spending time together.
3. Aria says, “I just know Mona is bad news. I can feel it.”
4. Ezra gives two different explanations for the same event.
File 05 • Multiple-choice challenge

Choose the perfect word

Only one answer fits each sentence naturally. Think about meaning and collocation.

1. The final scene was so ______ that I kept thinking about it for days.
2. The director's idea was original and unexpected. It was a ______.
3. The reference to an old episode was completely ______ me.
4. Her explanation made no sense and seemed designed to impress everyone. It sounded ______.
5. The story of being betrayed really ______ me.
6. The plot felt ______ because it repeated ideas from dozens of other teen dramas.
7. She stopped to ______ every detail of the mysterious room.
8. The bright pink decorations were so loud that they looked ______.
File 06 • Continue the sentence

Make it sound like C1

Complete these sentence starters with your own ideas. Aim for nuanced, interesting answers rather than simple statements.

1. Aria would have been more convincing if...
2. What makes Mona particularly difficult to trust is...
3. The fact that Ezra's behaviour seems suspicious does not necessarily mean...
4. Not until Aria has considered the evidence carefully can she...
5. Had Mike been more open with his sister,...
6. What might leave Aria cold is...
7. The most thought-provoking question in this storyline is...
8. Under no circumstances should someone...
File 07 • Storytelling lab

Three clues. One explanation.

Choose one story mission. You have to create a short scene with a beginning, a twist and an ending. Make it dramatic, but believable.

Mission A: The message

Aria sees a message on Mike's phone. It contains only three words: “She knows everything.” Who is “she”? What does Mona know?

Mission B: The photograph

A photograph appears online. Ezra is in the background, but he claims he was somewhere else that evening. Aria has to decide whether to confront him.

Mission C: The unexpected ally

Mona tells Aria something that could help her, but accepting the information means trusting someone she has never fully trusted.

Your storytelling ingredients

Include at least five of these:

a haunting imagea subtle toucha bold choicea talking pointan evocative detailto zone outto linger overto soak upto strike a chord

Word count: 0

Storytelling follow-up

  • Which clue was the most convincing?
  • Did your character act rationally or emotionally?
  • What would make the audience question your version of events?
  • Could there be another explanation for the same clues?
File 08 • The Mona question

Is Mona bad, or simply misunderstood?

Consider these possible interpretations. For each one, explain whether you agree, disagree or need more information.

1. Mona is strategic, not necessarily malicious.

Can someone be clever, secretive and still have good intentions?

2. Aria's suspicion may be understandable, but her reaction may be excessive.

Can a feeling be valid even when the conclusion is wrong?

3. Mike has a right to make his own decisions, even if Aria dislikes them.

Where is the boundary between protecting a sibling and controlling them?

4. Trust is not the same as blind faith.

What should someone do when a person repeatedly gives inconsistent explanations?

Choose a side, then defend it

File 09 • The Ezra mystery

Red flags or unreliable assumptions?

Aria notices details that make her question Ezra. But what is the difference between a genuine warning sign and a suspicion that grows because someone is already anxious?

A red flag

A repeated pattern of dishonesty, manipulation, disrespect or boundary-crossing.

A missing piece

Something unexplained that deserves a question, but is not proof by itself.

A projection

Interpreting someone else's behaviour through your own fear or past experience.

Discuss these scenarios

  1. Someone refuses to answer a reasonable question. Is that suspicious or simply private?
  2. A person tells two different versions of the same story. What would you ask next?
  3. Your friends dislike your boyfriend, but you feel happy with him. Should their opinion matter?
  4. You discover that someone has kept an important secret. Does the reason for the secret matter?
  5. Can jealousy make someone notice real problems, or invent problems that are not there?
  6. Is it possible to be both in love and genuinely worried about someone's behaviour?
Important distinction: A healthy relationship allows questions, boundaries and honest conversations. You do not need to prove that someone is a villain before deciding that a situation is not right for you.
File 10 • The speaking room

Speak like a C1 investigator

Answer aloud in full sentences. Try to speak for 30–60 seconds per question. Give reasons, examples and qualifications.

Round 1: Character analysis

  1. Is Aria naturally suspicious, or has her environment taught her not to trust people?
  2. Does she overreact, or does she simply refuse to ignore uncomfortable details?
  3. Is Mona more interesting as a villain, an ally or an unpredictable character?
  4. Does Mike have a responsibility to explain his friendship with Mona to Aria?
  5. Is Ezra's secrecy more worrying because Aria trusts him?

Round 2: Big ideas

  1. Can too much suspicion destroy a relationship even when there is nothing to hide?
  2. Is intuition a reliable guide, or does it often disguise fear?
  3. Do people deserve a second chance after lying?
  4. Can someone be a good person and still make manipulative decisions?
  5. Is it more damaging to trust the wrong person or to distrust the right person?

Round 3: The uncomfortable questions

  1. Would you rather know an unpleasant truth or remain happy without knowing?
  2. When does protecting someone become controlling them?
  3. Is keeping a secret always a betrayal?
  4. Would you confront someone immediately or wait until you had proof?
  5. Can a relationship recover after trust has been broken?
Useful C1 phrases: “I would argue that...”; “It is tempting to assume that...”; “That interpretation overlooks...”; “There is a distinction between...”; “I am not entirely convinced that...”; “What makes this particularly complicated is...”; “One could make the case that...”; “We should not jump to the conclusion that...”
File 11 • Final verdict

Who is the real problem?

You are presenting your findings to the other investigators. Give each character a verdict, but explain the evidence behind it.

ARIA

Too impulsive / understandably cautious / both / neither?

MONA

Manipulative / misunderstood / strategic / impossible to judge?

MIKE

Independent / secretive / caught in the middle / responsible for the confusion?

EZRA

Trustworthy / suspicious / misunderstood / someone who needs to explain himself?

Your final statement

Finish this sentence and deliver a 60-second closing argument:

“The biggest mistake Aria could make is not trusting Mona or Ezra. It is...”

Revisit your opening theory

Would you keep your original opinion, or has the evidence changed your mind?

Popular Posts